Banner Top

The Complete Guide to the Best Indestructible Dog Toys

Introduction

If you’re like many dog parents who spend tons of money on toys, and your backyard is starting to look like a toy graveyard because of all the half-eaten dolls, balls, bones, and ropes that never stood a chance against your dog, then it’s time to consider getting an indestructible dog toy instead.

In this mega-guide, we reveal everything you need to know about how to choose durable dog toys that will stand the test of time and provide your four-legged family member with endless fun. This is the Complete Guide to the Best Indestructible Dog Toys, and in it, we’ve listed 10 of the best indestructible dog toys that your dog won’t be able to destroy (try as he might).

Why Buy Indestructible Toys?

There are many benefits to choosing indestructible dog toys over the ordinary ones. The truth is that most soft, rubber, plush, and dog chew toys just don’t cut it, and if your dog destroys new toys within minutes, you’re not alone.

The majority of dogs have an enormous bite force that quickly destroys weaker materials. This means that most toys definitely won’t stand a chance, and you’ll find yourself buying new toys constantly. In fact, I’m willing to bet that if you’re reading this article then you’re experiencing one or more of the scenarios below:

  • Your dog instantly destroys weak toys
  • You’re tired of constantly replacing toy after toy
  • Your dog is in serious need of a challenge

If that sounds familiar, then read on because there’s a huge selection of affordable tough dog toys to choose from, and this guide will help you pick the best toy that will keep your dog entertained. But first, let’s look at…

How Long Do Most Dog Toys Last?

Some toys that claim to be indestructible don’t actually pass the test. Many pet owners buy these so-called ‘indestructible’ toys only to find that they get destroyed within minutes. This is particularly true when it comes to stuffed or plush toys. Rubber toys may last a bit longer than the stuffed ones, but they too will disappoint you in the end.

No matter what the label says, the toys just never seem to fare well when matched against a dog’s jaws.

Having gone through hundreds of toys in the last few years, including balls, oddly-shaped rubber toys, and pull toys (all of which claimed to be indestructible…) and after researching dozens of toys that are available on the market right now, I’m able to say that there are a few really indestructible toys that actually deliver on their promise, and that’s why I’ve created this list of the 10 best indestructible dog toys to choose from. I’ve selected only the truly tough dog toys that your canine friend won’t be able to destroy.

What Are Indestructible Dog Toys?

Indestructible dog toys are those that will not come apart the way other toys do when your dog rips into them. They are made of much stronger materials like poly plastic or durable rubber. They are harder for dogs to chew through, particularly if your dog is a destructive chewer.

Dogs that chew excessively do so for various reasons including the following:

  • Out of boredom
  • As an outlet for anxiety
  • For relaxation or recreation
  • Out of habit

Dogs may chew simply because they were left alone with nothing that they could amuse themselves with. Or it could be that they just like chewing on stuff. So, if you don’t want them getting into your shoe closet, then it’s better to provide them with something that they can safely chew on and satisfy the urge without damaging any of your valuable property.

But, you can’t give dogs just any toy. Their powerful jaws will quickly tear apart soft or poorly constructed toys in minutes, and should this happen, your dog may accidentally or intentionally eat part of the toy which could result in them choking or developing intestinal obstructions. That’s why, for the sake of your dog’s health, it’s recommended that you purchase durable dog toys.

If you’re skeptical about a toy that can withstand a dog’s rigorous chewing, then you’re not alone.

A lot of people have lost faith in toys that make such claims because they once bought a toy labeled ‘indestructible’ for their dog, only to see it shredded right before their eyes. A lot of toys out there don’t even hold up to a puppy’s playtime antics – let alone a full grown dog that has a lot of experience ripping through toys.

But luckily, there are some brands that focus on producing high-quality dog toys that truly are indestructible and designed to withstand the aggressive chewing habits of large dogs. Listed below are some of the most common types of dog toys that you can choose from.

Types of Indestructible Dog Toys:

  • Balls
  • Bones
  • Squeaky toys
  • Chew toys
  • Plush toys
  • Stuffable toys
  • Rope toys
  • Frisbees

What Makes A Dog Toy Indestructible?

As previously mentioned, I’ve listed only the best toys from the most trusted brands in this guide. These are the ones who mean it when they say ‘tough dog toy’. And while there isn’t really a toy that is 100% indestructible, this is as close to indestructible dog toys as you will ever come.

Each of the products listed below is made from super-strong materials that are guaranteed to survive your dog. Not only that, but these toys are also dishwasher-safe, non-toxic, and made right here in the US. They are guaranteed to be a favorite of both the customers and their furry best friends.

How To Choose The Best Indestructible Dog Toy For Your Pet

Even if your dog is rough and rips through ordinary toys like they’re made of butter, he still deserves to have a few solid toys in his life. After all, you don’t want him to get bored and start tearing through the house wreaking havoc!

But it’s not just about picking the first indestructible dog toy that you come across either. The wrong type of toy won’t last long with a tough chewer. You have to choose the best and most durable dog toys for your dog based on a variety of factors that we’re going to discuss below.

Get The Right Material

If you have a tough dog who’s very rough with the toys, then there are obviously some materials and types of toys that you’ll have to avoid such as squeaker toys, plush or fleece toys, and latex or vinyl toys.

While squeaker toys may be a lot of fun for most dogs, the risks are high that tough chewers will easily tear through the squeaky toy in their quest to find the squeaker. After they find their treasure, they usually eat it, which is bad.

Plush or fleece toys, however adorable, just aren’t a great option for your tough boy or girl. As much as you may enjoy seeing your dog try to take a bite out of a Darth Vader toy, it’s not a good choice for a tough chewer. They will just rip right through that type of toy and eat the insides leading to discomfort, digestive issues, and possibly even some serious medical issues.

Toys that are made from latex or vinyl are also cute and fun for pets to play with, but they aren’t ideal for tough dogs because when they bite through them, it could create sharp edges that have the potential to hurt your dog’s mouth, causing extreme discomfort or pain. This could also lead to infection.

So choose the material based on your pet’s ability to demolish toys. Pick only tough dog toys materials for aggressive chewers and toy destroyers. You may have to pick a toy that doesn’t squeak, spin, shake, or glow – but it will definitely last where many others fail.

Get The Right Size

To choose the best indestructible dog toy, you also need to keep size in mind. You want to get a toy that is ideal for your dog’s size. If you get toys that are too small, the larger dogs could choke on them. When buying toys for dogs, apply the same discretion that you would for babies. If it constitutes a choking hazard, then don’t buy it. Your dog toys should always be too big to swallow.

Get The Toughest Brands

Many companies that make dog toys market them as ‘tough’ and ‘indestructible’ but in reality, very few of them actually pass the test. So, which are the toughest brands on the market? That is the million dollar question!

According to the dozens of hours of research that we conducted, as well as hundreds of online reviews from customers all over the world, we’ve found the three toughest brands that produce high-quality indestructible toys for dogs.

The three manufacturers listed below have proven over time that they are the best when it comes to creating the toughest, most durable toys capable of withstanding your chewer’s powerful jaws.

west-paw-zogoflex-dog-bone

1. West Paw Design

This dog toy brand does a magnificent job of creating indestructible toys for tough chewers. Their toys are made from recyclable, FDA-compliant material which is totally safe for your little toy terminators. All West Paw Design products are made in the US and come with a 100% guarantee to withstand tough chewers which mean that if your dog manages (somehow) to destroy the toy, you can send it back and get a new one – all at no cost to you.

kong-extreme-ball

2. Kong

The Kong Ball is this brand’s most famous toy. Kong manufactures durable dog toys that are among the toughest on the market. In addition to the Kong ball, they also provide other types of balls, toys, and snacks.

The majority of Kong toys have a hole in them that you can fill with goodies and treats to keep your canine companion occupied while you are away. This brand provides a wide variety of options to choose from, and that’s why it has quickly grown to become one of the leading indestructible dog toy manufacturers in the world.

nylabone-dura-chew-toy

3. Nylabone

This company’s specialty is dental dog chew products that are not only fun for your dog to play with but also great for promoting good canine hygiene. Their indestructible dog toys are a favorite among veterinarians, and they come in a wide range of designs and sizes which means that you’ll be sure to find something that your pet will absolutely love from their massive inventory.

To be honest, there aren’t that many dog toys out there that are truly tough and durable, and there are even less that are truly indestructible. However, you’ll never go wrong with dog toys from these three brands. Of course, there are a few other brands that also produce tough toys, but these are far better than all the rest.

So What Do All The Indestructible Dog Toys On Our List Have In Common?

  • They are very durable and made to last
  • These toys are ideal for tough chewers
  • None of these toys squeak
  • They don’t have stuffing
  • These toys are perfect for indoor games
  • They are great for keeping your dog occupied for hours on end

10 Best Indestructible Dog Toys to Choose From

After sifting through hundreds of toys, here are the top 10 tough dog toys that made the list:

1. West Paw Dog Bone

This tough dog bone from West Paw is a genuine win and the ideal toy for aggressive chewers. It’s great for chew time or playing fetch. It comes in a variety of colors and sizes, and it also floats in water, which makes it perfect for playing games with your dog at the pool or beach.

The Hurley Tough toy comes with a 100% guarantee to withstand any damage from your dog, and if your dog should find a way to destroy it, then a new one will be sent to you free of charge.

This bone is not only easy to clean, but also super safe for your beloved pet as it is BPA and Phthalate free, contains no toxic materials, and is FDA-compliant. As with all their other toys, these are made in the US (Bozeman, Montana, to be precise).

Pros:

  • This toy is easy to clean – just throw it in the dishwasher
  • The Hurley bone floats, so you can play with it in the water
  • It’s made from a type of material that is very tough and durable
  • The company offers great support and customer care!

Cons:

There are a couple of reviews online which show that some dogs have actually proved up to the challenge of tearing these bones apart, which means they aren’t totally indestructible. But, on the plus side, support will send you another one ASAP without issues.

2. Nylabone T-Rex

This durable dental dinosaur toy is among the Nylabone favorites. It comes in a variety of different dinosaurs and provides teeth-cleaning benefits while your pup wrestles with a t-rex. It’s designed specifically for the toughest chewers and has bristles and rounded nubs that help to control plaque and slow tartar build up in your pet’s teeth.

These toys are considerably more fun than brushing your dog’s teeth! The Nylabone T-Rex is suitable for dogs up to 50lbs in weight. And if a t-rex just isn’t awesome enough for you, it comes in several other dino shapes like the Brontosaurus and Stegosaurus.

If you can’t choose among them, then simply go for the entire set of Nylabone dinosaur chew toys!

Pros:

  • Dog toys from this brand are extremely durable and tough
  • The toy cleans your dog’s teeth as it plays and chews on it
  • They come in a cool range of dinosaur shapes
  • These toys are affordably priced

Cons:

There aren’t really any ‘cons’ to speak of, but some dogs may not fancy these types of chew toys simply due to preference. However, judging by the killer online reviews from other owners, that is very unlikely.

3. Mammoth 3-Knot Tug Rope

This massive flossy chew rope is available in various lengths and sizes and comes with double benefits. It cleans your dog’s teeth as you play.

The size that you opt for will obviously depend on your particular dog’s size, but no matter which one you go with, you can rest assured that you and your dog will absolutely love this toy – him for the loads of fun it brings, and you for its rope fibers that floss your dog’s teeth while he’s chewing and tugging at the rope. This significantly promotes your canine friend’s dental health.

The rope comes in a vast array of bright colors and designs, some with different color ropes woven together to create a fun pattern. So if you have a super chomper at home, this is a great toy for them to play with. As far as durable dog toys go, this one is definitely a winner!

Pros:

  • The tug rope is 2 inches thick, which makes it super durable and tough
  • It also comes with 3 knots which makes it easy to keep your fingers away from your dog’s mouth during tug or war games!

Cons:

None that we know of!

4. West Paw Stuffable Treat Toy

This toy from West Paw dispenses treats for your dog. It’s extremely tough and designed for aggressive chewers who just love to gnaw. The stuffable treat toy is 100% guaranteed to outlast your dog’s determination to destroy it and comes with a hollow space where you can insert goodies or treats into it and dispenses them as your dog plays.

You can stuff this toy with treats to encourage your dog to engage and play with the toy. This keeps him stimulated for long periods of time. The dog toy also floats and bounces which means even more hours of canine fun. You can play with it in the water, use it for playing fetch, or whatever else comes to mind.

It’s basically a one-stop shop for fun times with your dog. In addition to all that, it’s super easy to clean by simply tossing it into the dishwasher for a quick and easy clean.

Pros:

  • This toy stands up to tough chewers like no other toy in its category
  • It comes with a solid 100% guarantee against damage or destruction
  • Dispenses treats to keep your dog engaged for longer
  • This toy floats, bounces, and flies which means more fun for your dog

Cons:

There are a few rare reported instances where canines have managed to bust through this chew toy (probably looking for more treats inside). But, this isn’t really of concern as the company is very efficient about sending replacements in such cases – so, not really a ‘con’.

5. Tuffy Mega Boomerang

This is one of the few indestructible dog toys made out of fabric. It comes in several different colors and various patterns that include brick, tiger, or a chain link design. But don’t discount this toy simply because of the material it’s made from. The fabric used is an innovative technology that can withstand your dog’s tough teeth.

It has lots of layered luggage-grade material and tough cross stitching which offer additional protection and safety. You don’t see many tough dog toys on the market with that type of webbing and stitching. It also floats making it ideal for pool time antics with your dog.

The Mega boomerang is machine washable and easy to get clean after a chewing session. You can use it as a Frisbee for playing fetch or for tug of war. Either way, your beloved pet is in for tons of fun when you bust the Tuffy Boomerang out. This is a rare soft toy that tough chewers can actually enjoy.

Pros:

  • Unlike most other toys on this list, this one is a soft but tough and durable chew toy
  • It’s machine washable and extremely easy to keep clean
  • Has extra layers of stitching and webbing to protect your dog

Cons:

There aren’t really any. According to the majority of online reviews left by people who purchased the Tuffy, they found it to be fantastic!

6. West Paw Tug-of-War Toy

Dogs all over the world love this colorful interactive toy, and yours will too. This Zogoflex Bumi toy from West Paw is extremely durable and it also comes with the manufacturer’s 100% toughness guarantee. This toy also floats in water, which makes it the ideal accessory to bring with you on those fun trips to the beach with your dog.

According to the vast majority of online reviews from satisfied customers, the Bumi Tug-of-war toy is an awesome product that both aggressive chewers and humans enjoy tugging away at. It can stretch up to twice its length, giving it unlimited tugging potential for use either as a tug toy or for playing fetch.

It has a unique ‘S’ shape which makes it more interactive for either two dogs or a human and canine to easily get in on the fun. While the West Paw Bumi toy is tough, it’s also designed to be gentle on the mouth as well as your dog’s teeth.

Pros:

  • Like all other West Paw indestructible dog toys featured here, this toy floats in water
  • Makes for some exciting games of tug-of-war even between the toughest dogs
  • Comes with a 100% guarantee to survive the most aggressive chewers

Cons:

As previously mentioned, there isn’t any toy that is totally indestructible, for every dog, all the time and there have been one or two god-like dogs that have been known to have the capacity to bust through this toy. Having said that, reports of this toy getting demolished are few and far between, and those cases are extreme outliers, which makes the West Paw Bumi Tug-of-war toy a safe bet.

7. The Kong Flyer

This rubber flyer from Kong is yet another amazing durable dog toy from the well-known brand. Great for throwing with your dog, the Kong flyer is tough, durable, and made from the trusted, non-toxic natural rubber that the company uses for the majority of their indestructible dog toys.

This toy is great for playing fetch and totally suited to even the toughest chewers. It’s super safe, and when compared to a lot of other toys made of harder materials such as the classic Frisbee made from plastic, the rubber is much softer on your canine’s teeth and gums.

It’s available in two sizes: small and large and comes in an assortment of bright colors. When compared to other tough dog toys like the traditional frisbees, this one comes out tops. No matter how much your pet loves to gnaw, with the Kong Flyer, they’ve met their match.

Pros:

  • This toy is much tougher than traditional flying discs
  • It’s made in the US and quality is 100% guaranteed
  • They have a cool range of stunning colors to choose from

Cons:

There are those who believe that Kong recently changed their Kong Flyer design and that the newer model doesn’t fly as well as the previous one…

8. Extreme Rubber Ball from Kong

This is yet another highly rated product from this leading dog toy manufacturer. It’s tough enough to survive the onslaught from the relentless teeth of aggressive chewers. It’s considered by most dog parents to be the ultimate in indestructible dog toys, and it’s a superb option for dogs that are pros at demolishing regular tennis balls.

It’s ultra bouncy and more durable than any other similar balls on the market. If your dog has perfected the art of chewing through toys, then this could be the ideal toy for him. It’s completely puncture-resistant and aimed specifically at those dogs that love to chew stuff.

Pros:

  • This toy has been proven to be long-lasting and durable
  • It’s very bouncy and provides lots of fun when your dogs are chasing it around
  • It’s an affordable high-quality product

Cons:

There aren’t any, except some people wonder why some Kong balls have holes drilled in the middle while others don’t. Either way, they perform really great and will provide hours of fun for your furry friend.

9. Benebone Chew Toy

This heavy-duty chew toy is great for all dog sizes. It’s tough and durable and will keep your dog busy for hours. Compared to the majority of other chew toys on our list, this is one of the less expensive ones, but as with most other products of this kind – you get what you pay for.

This means that while it’s cheaper than the other toys, it does exhibit some slight damage at the ends after some time, although it’s nothing when compared to the damage that other ‘not-so-indestructible’ toys incur under the same level of attack.

Manufactured in the US, this toy actually comes with real bacon flavor. That’s right, it tastes like bacon! Your dog will definitely love this one. It also comes with a curved shape for easy handling, so good luck getting him to let this bone go.

Pros:

  • This toy is significantly cheaper than other indestructible chew toys
  • It has a bacon flavor that dogs go crazy for
  • The curved shape makes it easier for your dog to hold onto it

Cons:

This toy, while extremely durable and tough, still isn’t as tough as the other toys listed here.

10. Max Glow Ball

This ball is so light that you would have a hard time believing that it will last more than a week, but it does! In fact, online reviews from people who purchased these products for their dogs reveal that they are surprisingly durable dog toys that last a long time, despite their small weight.

One dog owner states that he was pleasantly surprised to realize that his dog’s Max glow ball had lasted over two years when most of his other toys were long since dead and buried.

Not too sure what sort of magical compound it’s made out of, but it certainly is impressive. The ball is actually light enough that you can play fetch with your dog indoors without worrying about breaking stuff around the house.

AND, it glows in the dark! It gives off a bright light when the lights go off, which most dogs love. The only real downside to this toy is that whenever your dog bites down on it, it makes a squishy noise. While this isn’t really a big deal, it could prove irritating for some people. But, if you’re immune to such things, then this is a great toy to get for your beloved pet.

Pros:

  • The Max glow ball is light enough for playing games indoors
  • It has a durable and long-lasting design
  • The ball glows in the dark

Cons:

This toy makes a squishy noise when the dog bites it

And that brings us to the end of ‘The Complete Guide to the Best Indestructible Dog Toys’. Use this guide as your resource to help you make the best toy choices that your beloved dog will cherish for years to come.

Don’t forget to check out our other articles on Dog Accessories.

0 Comments

Leave a Comment